To my surprise Why can't I remap q has been closed as OT.
What makes it off topic? (I don't want to argue or discuss but merely get some insight)
Edit Changed a bit the phrasing of my answer because I confused @guntbert (OP of this meta question) thinking they were @Joe Compton (OP of the referenced question)
I marked it as off topic because of the following reason:
This question was caused by a problem that can no longer be reproduced or a simple typographical error.
I marked it because Joe Compton already had written an answer so their reputation is not impacted but future readers are unlikely to benefit from the question as it is unlikely that they make the same typographical mistake.
However it doesn't indicate a poor quality of the question, just an unlikely re usability.